Why Self-Care Stops Working After Grief
Why Self-Care Stops Working After Grief

Why Self-Care Stops Working After Grief

When we name that we have a loss to grieve, the list of self-care ideas grows faster than a dandelion. With the best of intentions, our loved ones collaborate quickly to surround us with invitations to coffee, reminders to read what makes us happy, and to tidy up our space – it’ll feel better. But…you and I both know what once felt right can become just another task to complete when we are grieving. So this week, we’re going to unpack why self-care stops working for us when we’re grieving and find what we really need: a pathway toward restoration.


When I say self-care, what comes to mind?

If you’re anything like me, or honestly just a woman who’s spent any amount of time on the internet in the last decade, you probably picture a day off. Maybe it’s coffee with a friend, a pastry that costs more than it should, a facial, a massage, or wandering Target without a list and somehow calling it therapy. These are the little treats we’ve collectively decided count as self-care, and there’s nothing inherently wrong with them.

I enjoy those things, too. But grief has a way of exposing the difference between what feels good for a moment and what actually helps us sustain ourselves over time.

After loss, many of us discover that the things that used to refill us don’t quite work the way they once did. We can take the day off, buy the candle, schedule the massage, meet a friend for coffee, and still find ourselves exhausted, overwhelmed, or disconnected. That can feel frustrating, especially when everyone around us keeps suggesting the same solutions and genuinely wants them to help.

The problem isn’t that we’re doing self-care incorrectly. The problem is that grief isn’t stress.

Most of the self-care advice we’re given is designed to help us recover from stress. It’s built for busy schedules, demanding jobs, overcommitted calendars, and the ordinary wear and tear of daily life. Grief asks something different of us. Rather than recovering from a difficult season, we’re adapting to a reality that no longer looks the way it did before. Loss changes our capacity, our priorities, our relationships, our sense of identity, and sometimes even our understanding of what matters most.

When we’re grieving, we’re not trying to bounce back. We’re learning how to live inside a life that has been altered by what we’ve experienced. That’s why I’ve started thinking less about self-care as indulgence and more about restoration.

For me, restorative care is anything that helps us reconnect with enough safety, capacity, support, and steadiness to participate in our lives again. Sometimes that looks like rest. Sometimes it looks like asking for help. Sometimes it means eating lunch hours later than intended because it’s the first moment we’ve noticed our own hunger. Sometimes it means recognizing that the things we need now are different from the things we needed before loss changed us.

One of the challenges is that our needs often change much faster than our awareness does. We know something feels harder, but we don’t always know why. We know we’re struggling, but we can’t necessarily identify what would help. Meanwhile, the people around us continue relating to the version of us they knew before the loss, and the culture around us rarely slows down long enough to acknowledge that grief affects nearly every aspect of how we function.

Life keeps moving. Work still expects productivity. Families still need care. Laundry still accumulates. Emails still arrive. The practical demands of living don’t pause while we’re trying to make sense of what’s happened.

As a result, many grieving people spend a tremendous amount of energy trying to appear okay. We continue reaching for the solutions that worked in the past because they’re familiar and because they’re often the only solutions we’ve been offered. When those solutions stop helping, it’s easy to assume something is wrong with us rather than recognizing that our needs have changed.

I’ve also noticed that when we’re in need of care, the silence around us can feel very different than it once did. What used to feel calming can suddenly feel threatening. Our thoughts may feel less familiar, our emotions may feel louder, and the ways we once soothed ourselves can feel strangely inaccessible. The person we’ve relied on for comfort, ourselves, suddenly feels harder to reach.

That means that when we need tenderness the most, we often have the least access to it.

The people who love us are usually trying their best. They offer distractions, gifts, outings, treats, and encouragement because those are the forms of care they’ve been taught to recognize. Sometimes those things are genuinely helpful. Other times they miss the mark because what we need isn’t another treat. We need to be treated more gently. We need curiosity instead of correction. We need space instead of pressure. We need support that recognizes the reality of what we’re carrying rather than trying to convince us we’re carrying less than we are.

Recently, a dear friend of mine had a medical emergency in the middle of an already exhausting season of life. Normally on the go and ready to serve others, she found herself bedridden and unable to handle the littlest tasks.

After a few weeks of bringing meals and checking in, I called to say I was coming over with coffee, breakfast, and a 90-minute window of time to clean whatever she needed handled.

I knew the list was long, and I thought for sure I would be scrubbing the bathroom top to bottom or handling a few loads of laundry. Maybe even deep cleaning the fridge, because we all know how good it feels to see what you have to cook without having to dig.

But in this case, she needed to simply borrow my brain power. So, we sat for the whole time, talking through some unmade decisions that had her feeling unsettled. By the time I left, we’d finalized the decisions and she felt seen, cared for, and a little less trapped in her overwhelm. She didn’t need more motivation, more positivity, or even more rest. She needed less to carry.

This is such a practical care offering for grieving people – helping them offload the invisible and ongoing tasks that consume so much energy. Things like laundry, meal planning, decision making, scheduling, and the countless mental tabs that never seem to close can become surprisingly heavy when grief is already demanding so much of our internal resources.

When it comes to reorganizing our own needs, I’ve learned that sometimes the most restorative thing we can do isn’t add another self-care practice to our lives. Restoration also comes from removing something. It comes from creating a little more space, a little more margin, and a little less pressure.

I also love taking people on walks because movement often feels more accessible than conversation alone. Occasionally, I like gifting journals, good pens, tea, and blankets because they invite comfort without demanding performance. Sometimes I wish I could simply hand every grieving person a day completely free from responsibility, expectation, and decision making. Not because rest fixes grief, but because grieving itself requires energy, and most people are trying to grieve while carrying a workload that assumes nothing significant has changed.

When I think about restorative care now, I find myself returning to a different question. Instead of asking whether something will make me feel better, I wonder whether it supports me in heart, mind, body, and spirit. Instead of asking whether it will help me get back to normal, I wonder whether it helps me care for the person I am becoming.

One of the most consistent changes in who we are is our capacity to interact with others and with ourselves, especially in a joyful way. I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about the difference between whimsy and spontaneity in grief. I think we easily lose sight of our playful sides, but there’s a very important bridge back to that part of our humanity that we can overlook if we don’t reorganize our understanding of grief as more than a stressor.

People often talk about spontaneity as though it’s inherently healing, but I don’t think that’s always true for grieving people. When your world has already been disrupted by loss, additional uncertainty can feel demanding rather than freeing. Spontaneity asks for flexibility and capacity that may not be available yet. It can feel like one more thing you’re expected to accommodate when you’re already stretched thin.

Whimsy feels different.

Whimsy doesn’t require anything from us. It arrives as an invitation rather than a demand. It might be a ridiculous gift, like a Magic 8 Ball sitting on a desk (to ease hard choices, obviously). You might see a flower growing through a crack in the sidewalk and let yourself daydream about the story of the seed that started it all.

Or maybe you finally notice the colors and the science and the levity of a little soap bubble, and it takes your breath away.

What makes whimsy meaningful isn’t that it distracts us from grief. It’s that it briefly reconnects us to parts of ourselves that grief can make harder to access.

Loss has a way of narrowing our world for a while. Our attention becomes consumed by survival, logistics, responsibilities, uncertainty, and pain. We spend so much energy getting through the day, getting through the appointment, getting through the conversation, or getting through the next task that there isn’t much room left for anything else.

Whimsy gently interrupts that pattern. It reminds us that we’re still capable of curiosity. Still capable of delight. Still capable of imagination, creativity, and play.

Those parts of us may feel quieter after loss. They may take longer to find. But they are not gone.

In that sense, whimsy can become a form of restoration. It doesn’t ask us to perform resilience, positivity, or growth before we’re ready. It simply offers a moment of reconnection. A reminder that alongside the grief, there is still a whole person here.

For me, that’s why whimsy feels so important after loss. It helps us expand our relationship to reality around us, rather than continuing to bury our heads in the proverbial sand. For a brief moment, grief is no longer the only reality we can access.

Maybe self-care stops working after grief because we’re asking it to do a job it was never designed to do.

What we need after loss is often less about rewards and more about support. We need care that meets us where we actually are rather than where we used to be. We need practices, relationships, and rhythms that help us build enough capacity to keep participating in our lives while honoring the reality of what we’ve experienced.

And sometimes the most restorative thing we can do is stop trying to return to who we were before loss long enough to discover what this version of ourselves needs now. The goal was never to become our old selves again. The invitation is to build a life that can hold the person we’re becoming.


Thank you for listening to episode 264 of Restorative Grief. Self-care is an easy topic to talk about when life is easy. We have a few stressors, and we’ve found simple resets that bring us back to ourselves. But grief is much more than a stressor; it’s more like…a blender. A tornado. A song whose lyrics you can’t memorize no matter how many times you’ve listened. Grief makes very little sense, sometimes, which is why our self-care (and our sense of self altogether) becomes equally confusing. If that’s you, consider joining our Patreon to snag this week’s workbook so you can uncover your first step toward a new definition of self-care on this side of grief.

If this is your first time listening to the podcast, I’m so grateful you’re here! Thank you for trusting your inner voice that encouraged you to hit play, and hopefully, to hit subscribe, too. Please take the time to leave a review and invite someone else to listen along. Thank you as always to my current Patrons; you make this work so worthwhile! And as always, before we go, one last thing. Please remember, the only solution for grief is to do the work of grieving. Thank you for listening. I’ll see you next week.

Links + Resources from this episode: